The Dilemma of Removing Old Trees: Navigating the Why and Why Not

When it comes to being mindful of the environment, deciding to cut down an old tree, especially one as old as a 175-year-old elm, is a big deal. It’s a complicated choice that involves thinking about how important mature trees are for the environment, while also considering the practical reasons that might make us need to cut them down. Let’s look at why we might think about taking down old trees and the arguments that support keeping them.

In 2016, we safely removed this 175-year-old Elm Tree with conflicted feelings of sadness, excitement, exhaustion, worry, and hope.

Why We Might Cut Down Old Trees?

1. Safety Concerns:

Sometimes, old trees can become unsafe. They might have problems with their structure, diseases, or decay that can make them unstable. In these cases, cutting them down is necessary to keep people and property safe.

2. Infrastructure and Urban Planning:

In cities, old trees can get in the way of roads, sidewalks, and utility lines. Removing them might be necessary to plan and build things in the city safely.

3. Disease and Infestation:

Old trees are more likely to get sick or have bug problems. If a tree is too sick and could spread diseases to other plants, or if it’s infested with bugs, it might need to be removed.

4. Property Damage Prevention:

Large, old trees with big root systems can damage buildings and sidewalks. Removing them can prevent expensive repairs and keep structures safe.

Why We Might Keep Old Trees?

1. Good for the Environment:

Old trees are crucial for the environment. They provide homes for many animals, add to biodiversity, and help fight climate change by soaking up carbon dioxide.

2. Historical and Cultural Significance:

Trees that have been around for a long time have historical and cultural importance. They’re like living monuments that connect us to the past.

3. Aesthetic and Recreational Value:

Old trees make places look beautiful and create nice spaces for people to relax. They contribute to a sense of community and well-being.

4. Air and Water Quality:

Older trees are great at cleaning the air by taking in pollutants and releasing oxygen. Their roots also help keep the soil healthy and prevent erosion, which is good for water quality.

Finding the Right Balance:

Balancing the decision to remove or preserve an old tree requires careful consideration of both environmental and practical factors. In cases where safety and practical concerns necessitate removal, efforts should be made to replant and restore greenery elsewhere. Preservation efforts should focus on regular maintenance, disease prevention, and measures to ensure the longevity of these living landmarks.